BR-DE-23-aBank transfer without account details
Also in:Deutsch
What it means
If the payment means says bank transfer (30 or 58), the invoice must say which account to pay into.
Official message
Rejects the invoice (fatal)[BR-DE-23-a] Wenn BT-81 "Payment means type code" einen Schlüssel für Überweisungen enthält (30, 58), muss BG-17 "CREDIT TRANSFER" übermittelt werden.XRechnung Schematron 2.6.0, KoSIT, released 2 September 2026 · Read the rule at the source
KoSIT publishes the XRechnung messages in German only.
Text compared with the published file on 17 November 2026.
Direct fix
Add <cac:PayeeFinancialAccount> to the PaymentMeans with <cbc:ID>DE02120300000000202051</cbc:ID> (the IBAN), optionally the account holder's name and the BIC in cac:FinancialInstitutionBranch. Not paid by transfer? Use the matching code, such as 59 for SEPA direct debit.
Typical causes
- Code 58 is the template default, but the bank account isn't linked to the invoice.
- The IBAN is printed in the PDF footer only.
- The company has several accounts and none is set as the default for e-invoices.
How to fix it
- Add your IBAN (and optionally BIC and account holder) to the payment means.
- Or choose the payment means code that matches how the customer pays.
Before and after
A real invoice from our sample library, cut down to the lines that matter. The first version fails BR-DE-23-a; the second passes.
The payment means says 58 (SEPA credit transfer), but there's no account to pay into, so BR-61 and BR-DE-19 fail too.
<cac:PaymentMeans> <cbc:PaymentMeansCode>58</cbc:PaymentMeansCode> <cbc:PaymentID>RE-2026-1187</cbc:PaymentID></cac:PaymentMeans><cac:PaymentMeans> <cbc:PaymentMeansCode>58</cbc:PaymentMeansCode> <cbc:PaymentID>RE-2026-1187</cbc:PaymentID> <cac:PayeeFinancialAccount> <cbc:ID>DE02120300000000202051</cbc:ID> <cbc:Name>Holzwerk Brandt GmbH</cbc:Name> <cac:FinancialInstitutionBranch> <cbc:ID>BYLADEM1001</cbc:ID> </cac:FinancialInstitutionBranch> </cac:PayeeFinancialAccount></cac:PaymentMeans>It’s one of our sample files, so checking it doesn’t count towards your free validations.
Check your invoice for BR-DE-23-a
Open the free validator with BR-DE-23-a already explained: paste or upload your XML and the finding, if any, is highlighted with its exact line.
Check my invoice3 free validations a month without an account. Invoice contents are never stored.
See it in action
These sample invoices break this rule. Open one to see the exact line.
Germany · XRechnung
Check this rule in German
The free German checker runs BR-DE-23-a and the other XRechnung rules in your browser, with the fix in German. Nothing is uploaded.
- XRechnung ValidatorPaste an XRechnung (UBL or CII) or a ZUGFeRD PDF and see 32 XRechnung rules (BR-DE) with the fix in German. Runs in your browser; nothing is uploaded.in German
- XRechnung vs. ZUGFeRDXRechnung or ZUGFeRD: how they are built, the profiles, and which format suits which customer.in German
Prefer English?XRechnung validatorGermany's e-invoicing obligation: 2025, 2027 and 2028
Where validators check it
For developers and software suppliers: the test exactly as the official Schematron runs it. The validator applies it to every element that matches the context and reports the rule wherever the test comes out false.
- Runs on (context)
/ubl:Invoice/cac:PaymentMeans[normalize-space(cbc:PaymentMeansCode) = ('30','58')] | /cn:CreditNote/cac:PaymentMeans[normalize-space(cbc:PaymentMeansCode) = ('30','58')]- Test
cac:PayeeFinancialAccount
Copied from XRechnung-UBL-validation.sch, XRechnung Schematron 2.6.0. Text compared with the published file on 17 November 2026.
- Runs on (context)
/rsm:CrossIndustryInvoice/rsm:SupplyChainTradeTransaction/ram:ApplicableHeaderTradeSettlement/ram:SpecifiedTradeSettlementPaymentMeans[normalize-space(ram:TypeCode) = ('30','58')]- Test
ram:PayeePartyCreditorFinancialAccount
Copied from XRechnung-CII-validation.sch, XRechnung Schematron 2.6.0. Text compared with the published file on 17 November 2026.
What the rule says (technical)
When the payment means code is a credit transfer (30 or 58), the credit transfer group (BG-17) must be given.
Add the payee's IBAN (and optionally BIC and account name) to the payment means.
More errors with a worked fix
Related rules
- BR-61Bank account for the transfer is missingAlso fails in the example above
- BR-DE-19IBAN for SEPA transfer isn't validAlso fails in the example above
- BR-DE-24-bCard payment mixed with account or direct debit detailsSame fields: BG-17, BT-81
- BR-DE-25-bDirect debit mixed with account or card detailsSame fields: BG-17, BT-81
- BR-CL-16Choose a recognised payment methodSame field: BT-81
- BR-49Payment method code is missingSame field: BT-81
- NL-R-008Payment method code not allowed between Dutch companiesSame field: BT-81
- BR-NL-12Payment method code not allowedSame field: BT-81